Ok, another cheap shot at posting Crimea stuff... but there's some real music here too :o) The BBC just let on that Coldplay
aren't so great.
Go figure. Apparently they plagurised a Joe Satiani track. Who? Never
mind, the below video explains it all. I'd post full tracks but Vox
editing clearly still sucks and it's already decided to kill my entire
post once today so I ain't pushing it...
Edit: Oh wait, there's more! Ok just how many songs did coldplay rip off? Rofl...
On a similar theme, here's a track by the band I love to spam,
The
Crimea. It's a re-recorded version of their track Baby Boom, and along
with sounding a whole lotdifferent from the original, it sounded a
whole lot like something else I'd heard. Took me an entire day to
figure it out though; after considering Morrissey, Sleeper, Echobelly,
and figuring it had to be something brit pop, I even thought about
asking that fountain of all musialknowledge Vu. No need though as I got
it eventually. Guesses in the comments please, answer tomorrow ;o)
-
ChristopherEDIT 12/13/08 VU: That first video was removed due to "a copyright claim by EMI Music". Ironic because the video is about infringing on copyrighted works. I don't think it should've been removed because it's fair-use with only excerpts of the chords.
Comments
Satriani was totally ripped off. I think this happens a lot more often than we think, but there is no excuse for it.
Honestly, "Viva La Vida" just sounds like dance music to me. I honestly can't picture any of those dudes owning any Satriani records (I know maybe three people who listen to Joe Satriani, and they're all technical guitar nuts; there's nothing there for the rest of us), but I could picture them listening to a lot of electronica. And to me, the vocal melody in that song just sounds like a pretty basic "club" sorta thing. The sort of thing that would be pretty easy for a songwriter to stumble onto.
As for Satriani - hey I own his Surfing with the Alien original CD, but I doubt Coldplay or anyone of their posse knew this guy/listen to his music, so I think it's all a coincidental. I mean, I'm surprise it doesn't happen more often with the similar chords.
Remember that Avril Lavigne saga? She settled out of court and paid the Rubinoos for having two lines sounding too similar (!! far out)
On top of that, the melody is actually different, too. They start in the same place, but they don't end anywhere close to each other.
It seems pretty unlikely that Coldplay would intentionally base a song off a couple non-repeated bars of a relatively obscure Joe Satriani song, honestly. Chris Martin has openly admitted taking influence from electronic music. If that song came from anywhere, there's no way that anywhere was Joe Satriani.
I want to meet that guy and steal his stuff! Hah!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z08W9O60g44
After 3:10.
Sound familiar?
So now it's Satch vs. 1970's Cat Stevens.